Skip to main content

Purpose

To seek to roll out a person-centred approach to the application of disciplinary policy and process across the public sector workforce in Wales which focusses on looking after individuals involved in the process as well as the application of the process itself. 

Background

Over the last decade, many NHS employers have reflected on their own practices when responding to workplace investigations and disciplinary action. Health boards and trusts have experienced growing financial pressures, staffing shortages, and increased demand all of which have impacted workloads and culture.

In July 2022, Aneurin Bevan University Health Board (ABUHB) launched the ‘Improving our Employee Investigations’ programme to improve the commissioning and delivery of its disciplinary policies. It was developed to address an overuse of the disciplinary policy and process within the organisation and the resulting impact on employee health and wellbeing, organisational culture and delivery of patient care and services.

Following an evaluation of the programme, ABUHB reported a significant impact: reduction of unnecessary investigations, with a high level of sickness days and financial costs averted. From January 2023, ABUHB worked with Health Education and Improvement Wales (HEIW) to offer the programme to all NHS Wales organisations through national training opportunities and tailored support. Velindre University NHS Trust reported savings of over £600,000 in sickness absence and the Welsh Ambulance Services NHS Trust received the HPMA’s first ‘avoidable employee harm’ award in autumn 2025.

The programme also informed the review of the NHS Wales Disciplinary Policy and Process (2026), emphasising the pursuit of informal resolution wherever appropriate, introduction of a standardised fact-finding assessment and ensuring a more person-centred approach. This was implemented from April 2026.

The work has been underpinned by a programme of academic research and engagement with key professional bodies, including the Chartered Institute for Personnel and Development (CIPD) and Healthcare People Management Association (HPMA). The HPMA launched its UK Avoiding Harm programme in October 2024, based on the NHS Wales’ work and research. Under Investigation, a book that brings the lessons and insight from the programme together was published by Bristol University Press in November 2025.

Testing the concept with sectors beyond healthcare, the CIPD in Wales ran a Senior People Professional Network event in December 2024, which suggested that the issues are systemic, not sector specific. This has been further tested in Rhondda Cynon Taf County Borough Council who introduced the programme and have already reported positive benefits. They also were ‘highly commended’ in the annual awards of the Public Services People Managers Association (PPMA) for the work in this area. In July 2026, the UK Faculty for Public Health published a discussion paper setting out that poorly applied disciplinary policies should be considered a public health issue.

Current situation

This new approach has been embraced by many NHS organisations in Wales and is being progressed through the NHS Wales Partnership Forum, which includes government, employers and trade unions. Consideration is now being given to a wider rollout of this approach across public sector workplaces other than the NHS. “Employee Investigations: Looking after your people and the process” is a trialled and tested training course, developed by ABUHB to help develop understanding of the process and help embed the culture change required to support this way of working. 

Benefits

Benefits of this way of working could be far reaching and could include employee wellbeing, workforce stability, financial benefits, improved culture, and improved organisational trust. This way of working should be supported by the relevant training to support culture change in workplaces. 

Next steps

  • To report into the Public Sector Future Workforce Forum (September 2026). 
  • To identify two pilot organisations (as a minimum) beyond NHS Wales to test the approach. 
  • To identify measurables to assess the impact, these could include data on number of workers going through a disciplinary process, staff turnover, costs involved. 
  • The TUC to run a programme of 3 regional training ‘taster sessions’ across Wales.