Skip to main content

Present

  • Rt Hon. Rhun ap Iorwerth MS (Chair)
  • Sioned Williams MS
  • Mabon ap Gwynfor MS
  • Anna Brychan MS
  • Heledd Fychan MS
  • Llŷr Gruffydd MS
  • Siân Gwenllian MS
  • Rt. Hon. Elin Jones MS
  • Adam Price MS
  • Dafydd Trystan Davies MS
  • Rt Hon. Elfyn Llwyd 
     
  • Cefin Campbell MS
  • Nerys Evans MS
  • Mark Hooper MS
  • Delyth Jewell MS 

Officials

  • Andrew Goodall, Permanent Secretary 
  • Rachel Garside-Jones, Director Office of the First Minister
  • Jo Salway, Director Cabinet Office 
  • Rebecca Dunn, Deputy Director Cabinet and Senedd Business Division
  • Toby Mason, Director Strategic Communications
  • Carwyn Wycherley, Deputy Head of Cabinet Office 
  • Aled ap Dafydd, Senior Special Adviser
  • Elin Roberts, Senior Special Adviser
  • Emily Edwards, Senior Special Adviser 
  • Francess Ifan, Senior Special Adviser
  • Christopher W Morgan, Cabinet Secretariat (minutes)
  • James Oxenham, Cabinet Secretariat 

Item 1: Minutes of previous meeting

1.1      Cabinet approved the minutes of 14th September.

Item 2: First Minister’s items

Highlights from the previous week

2.1 The Prif Weinidog referred to some of the highlights of the previous week, which included the publication of the Programme for Government, the launch of Nofio Ysgol/ the School Swimming Programme in Swansea, and visits to the Vishay Semiconductor plant and a mosque with a community energy project, both in Newport. 

Ireland – Britain Chamber of Commerce

2.2 The Prif Weinidog informed Cabinet that he would be attending the opening of the Wales branch of the Ireland – Britain Chamber of Commerce later that week. 

Item 3: Senedd Business

3.1 Cabinet noted that week’s Plenary grid, and the fact that two oral statements, on the national commission for Wales and public and preventative health, had been withdrawn from the agenda. 

3.2 It was reported that, at the start of Plenary the following day, the chair was likely to call for nominations from the Reform UK group for chair of the Legislation Committee. If there was more than one nomination or an objection to a single nomination, a secret ballot would be held with the outcome announced at the end of the meeting. 

3.3 Ministers noted that the Trefnydd had raised a point of order at the end of Plenary the previous Wednesday, in relation to comments made by Joe Martin MS.  It was understood that the Llywydd had written to the Member indicating that there had been a breach of Standing Order 13.9(v), and that he intended to make a ruling at the next opportunity.  This was likely to be at the start of Plenary on Tuesday.

Item 4: Proposal for North Wales National Park CAB(26-27)41

4.1 The Cabinet Minister for Government Effectiveness and the Constitution introduced the paper, which provided Cabinet with an update on the proposed response in relation to the Glyndŵr National Park Designation Order that had been submitted by Natural Resources Wales (NRW). 

4.2 It was important to recognise that the proposal originated under the previous administration as part of its Programme for Government commitments and was taken forward by NRW through the statutory designation process. It was not part of the current Government's manifesto, Programme for Government or First 100 Days commitments. 

4.3 However, irrespective of the Welsh Ministers policy priorities, there was a statutory process that would need to be followed. NRW had submitted a Designation Order to the Government in January 2026 and Ministers were now required to determine how to respond. Welsh Ministers may confirm the Order, confirm it with modifications, or refuse it. 

4.4 NRW had concluded that the proposed area met the statutory tests for National Park designation, which includes consideration of its natural beauty, cultural heritage, wildlife and environmental value and recreational opportunities it offers for open-air recreation.

4.5 The question before Ministers was whether designation was the correct mechanism at this time, taking account of a range of evidence, including the evidence base provided by NRW, responses to the associated consultations, affordability, wider Government priorities, stakeholder views and the availability of alternative approaches.

4.6 Having considered the evidence available, the Minister was minded to refuse to confirm the Designation Order. This provisional view reflected the significant long-term financial implications associated with establishing a new National Park Authority, the continued pressures on public finances, and the fact that all five Local Authorities within the proposed area objected to the Designation Order.  Furthermore, many of the environmental, landscape, tourism and rural development outcomes sought through the designation could potentially be pursued through existing and emerging policy frameworks and delivery mechanisms. 

4.7 In reaching this provisional view, the Minister had also taken into account the Government's priorities and Programme for Government, which placed an emphasis on delivering outcomes through a range of mechanisms and ensuring resources were directed towards current commitments. 

4.8 However, no final decision had been taken. Given the significance of the proposal, and recognising the strength of views both for and against designation, there would be a further opportunity for interested parties to submit evidence and representations before the final determination.   This additional engagement would allow the testing of the provisional conclusions, ensure that any further relevant evidence was considered, while demonstrating that all perspectives had been properly taken into account before a final decision was reached.

4.9 The evidence assembled through NRW's assessment and consultation process, together with any further representations received during the engagement period, should provide a sufficient basis for a final determination.

4.10 Following that process, the Minister would decide the next steps. 

4.11 Cabinet welcomed the paper and agreed the proposed approach, not least given that the five local authorities were opposed to the designation, 

4.12 Cabinet approved the paper.

Item 5: The Social Partnership and Public Procurement (Wales) Act 2023: Discharging the Social Partnership Duty on Welsh Ministers. CAB(26-27)34

5.1 The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Minister for Social Justice and Equality introduced the paper, which sought Cabinet’s agreement to a proportionate and practical approach to discharging the Welsh Ministers’ statutory social partnership duty under the Social Partnership and Public Procurement (Wales) Act 2023. 

5.2 The Act required Welsh Ministers to consult the Social Partnership Council (SPC) on decisions of a strategic nature relating to the steps taken to achieve the Well-being Objectives.  It was proposed that the focus should be on the key strategic drivers that shaped delivery of the Government's priorities.

5.3 Specifically, the SPC would be consulted annually on the principles and priorities underpinning the Welsh Government Budget, the Government's legislative programme and priorities and the annual review of the Well-being objectives and progress in achieving them.

5.4 This could be supplemented by consulting the SPC on major longer-term strategic decisions, such as spending reviews or future carbon budgets. Furthermore, when Ministers were developing long term strategic plans, it would be important to consider and highlight early in the process, where it would be helpful to share with the SPC. 

5.5 This approach would ensure that social partners were able to provide strategic input at a formative stage of decision-making, while avoiding an unmanageable requirement to consult on every policy or operational decision.

5.6 This would also allow the Government to discharge the duty by providing the SPC with an important role in considering strategic matters dealt with by the Government and key decisions taken collectively by Ministers.  This approach was consistent with the way the duty had been applied since it came into force. 

5.7 Cabinet welcomed the paper.

5.8 Cabinet approved the paper.

Item 6: Strategic Priorities for the Menai Strait Crossings and M4 around Newport CAB(26-27)37

6.1 The Deputy Minister for Transport introduced the paper, which presented the findings of the review into the Menai Strait crossings and the M4 around Newport.  These were nationally significant transport corridors and had a substantial impact on economic productivity, resilience and growth.  

6.2 The Menai Strait was primarily a resilience challenge, whereas, the M4 around Newport was a broader challenge involving congestion, reliability, resilience, freight movements and impacted connectivity across the south of the country.

6.3 In both cases, the evidence supported action on multiple fronts to address immediate issues, such as securing the existing infrastructure while delivering practical improvements over the coming years.  There would also be a need to progress the work required to deal with the wider strategic challenges that remained in the longer term.

6.4 In terms of the Menai Strait crossings, the review confirmed that the fundamental challenge remains resilience.  The Menai Suspension Bridge and Britannia Bridge were the only fixed links between Ynys Môn and the mainland and when either crossing was disrupted, the impact was significant.  

6.5 Officials had been asked to reconsider whether a three-lane tidal flow operation on Britannia Bridge could provide a solution.  However, the conclusion was unchanged. While technically feasible, the updated safety appraisal concluded that significant risks remained.  These included driver error, technology failure, narrow lane widths and the potential consequences of serious collisions.  The conclusion was tidal flow operation cannot currently be delivered at an acceptable level of safety.

6.6 It was proposed that the safety appraisal should be published and that there should be no further work on tidal flow operation at this stage.

6.7 However, it was recommended that there should be three complementary programmes of work, which would commence immediately and progress in parallel.  There would be continued management and operation of the existing crossings.  Investment in resilience measures including wind deflectors, variable speed limits, wider operational improvements, and immediate recommencement of development work for a third Menai Crossing. 

6.8 Cabinet was not currently being asked today to approve construction, but to restart the development work necessary to prepare for a third crossing.  Together, those measures would strengthen resilience now whilst progressing the preferred strategic solution identified by the review. 

6.9 In terms of the M4 around Newport, it had been agreed that there should not be another broad strategic review but to examine whether the substantial body of evidence already available was sufficient to inform decisions on the way forward.

6.10 The findings were clear that the challenges around Newport and its impact across the south of Wales remained significant. Congestion, poor reliability and resilience continued to affect people, freight and the wider economy.  The review also concluded that there was no single intervention capable of resolving those challenges.  In fact, no single option and no combination of options considered through the review, would fully remove congestion over the longer term.

6.11 The evidence pointed towards three complementary programmes of work that should begin immediately and progress in parallel. The package was intended to improve conditions immediately, while the Government continued to work to determine what further interventions might ultimately be required.

6.12 The first programme would continue investment in maintaining and renewing the existing motorway and wider Strategic Road Network.  This was not simply routine maintenance, as several major assets were approaching the end of their operational life.  Most notably, the Malpas Viaduct would require substantial renewal investment over the coming years.  Without intervention, these assets would increasingly require inspections, temporary traffic management, reactive repairs and operational restrictions.

6.13 Alongside this work, there should be a Five-Year Delivery Plan focused on practical interventions capable of delivering improved reliability, resilience and connectivity. The Arup review supported this approach. 

6.14 The Plan included motorway operational improvements, enhanced incident management measures and targeted interventions on the A48 Southern Distributor Road, including improvements to junctions and consideration of throughabout layouts where appropriate.

6.15 It also included measures to strengthen freight resilience, support appropriate use of alternative routes to maximise investment in the A465 and improve HGV parking and driver welfare facilities. There would be additional rail services and for the UK Government to accelerate delivery of the six stations recommended by the South-East Wales Transport Commission. There should also be improved bus connectivity between Newport and Cardiff.

6.16 Together, those interventions would provide a practical programme capable of beginning to deliver benefits within the next five years, with further benefits realised beyond that period.

6.17 There would also be a need to develop the next stage of the Long-Term Response, in the form of a dedicated 18-month programme of engineering, technical and appraisal work to develop the next stage of the long-term road-based and engineering response.   This programme would commence immediately alongside the maintenance programme and the Five-Year Delivery Plan.

6.18 It would determine whether there were deliverable long-term road-based and engineering solutions capable of making a significant difference to the challenges around Newport within the current policy, environmental and consenting framework.

6.19 The Arup review had examined the principal road-based and engineering options developed in previous years.  It concluded that further engineering, technical and appraisal work would be required before the Government could determine whether any road-based or engineering intervention could be taken forward.

6.20 Cabinet welcomed the paper and specifically the proposals to tackle congestion and improve connectivity across the Menai and the M4 around Newport along with the plans to improve welfare facilities for HGV drivers.

6.21 There would be a need to continue to make the case to the UK Government for the Barnett share of all infrastructure projects in England, such as HS2.

6.22 Cabinet approved the recommendations in the paper.

Cabinet Secretariat

September 2026