Skip to main content

Agenda Item 1: introduction

The Chair welcomed members to the fourth meeting of the Public Sector Future Workforce Forum (PSFWF) noting apologies and deputies. Three new members were introduced: Angie Feeney (Qualifications Wales) to replace Alison Standfast, Neil Butler (NASUWT) replacing Laura Doel and Beth Rees-Godfrey (WLGA) replacing Alyson Watkins. 

Agenda Item 2: reducing avoidable employee harm

The Chair reminded members that the Forum had previously expressed its in-principle support for the NHS's refreshed disciplinary approach, which placed greater emphasis on early and informal resolution wherever appropriate NHS Wales Disciplinary Policy. Members had agreed the approach should be included within the Resource Centre and had also requested a presentation from Aneurin Bevan University Health Board (ABUHB) who piloted it. And

rew Cooper (ABUHB) outlined the benefits of the approach for employers and employees, highlighting improvements in workplace culture, wellbeing and costs. A supporting programme of training/coaching had been developed to aid implementation. While the approach had been piloted beyond the NHS, particularly in local government, further opportunities remained to expand its use. AC also noted the support of TUC Cymru, which had developed complementary training and invited members to suggest future pilots. 

Key points raised during discussions included:

  • Welsh Government HR reported delivering training on the new approach to 90 staff members which had gone well. They will adopt the approach to complement existing policies.  
  • Trade unions highlighted the level of teacher suspensions in schools. While supportive of the new approach, they noted that schools were self-governing bodies and were not required to adopt it. More broadly, they also expressed concern about the continued reliance on disciplinary processes in professions governed by regulatory standards. 
  • Andrew Cooper asked whether a school could be identified to pilot the approach. 
  • Local Government and trade unions agreed to raise piloting a school at the Schools’ Partnership Forum and would also explore any opportunities to pilot other local authorities. 
  • Local Government representatives requested details of the local authorities involved in previous pilots and said they would also discuss piloting with Welsh Government education officials. 
  • Whilst offering support for a less bureaucratic disciplinary process, some members noted the importance of ensuring the system did not become overly relaxed and the need to maintain appropriate standards.

Action: Sharon Davies (WLGA) and Neil Butler (NASUWT) to raise piloting the new disciplinary approach with a school at the Schools’ Partnership Forum. 

Action: Sharon Davies (WLGA) and Neil Butler (NASUWT) to try and identify other local authorities that may be willing to participate in future pilots. 

Action: Andrew Cooper (Aneurin Bevan University Health Board) to provide the Secretariat with a list of local authorities involved in previous pilots, for sharing with the WLGA. 

Agenda Item 3: Work Strand 1 violence and harassment in the workplace (for discussion)

The Chair noted progress had been made at the Violence and Harassment in the Workplace Task and Finish Group, including a face-to-face workshop held on 15 June. Sharon Davies was invited to provide an update as follows:

  • The workshop reviewed evidence on workplace violence and harassment to identify areas of focus and outputs for the Task and Finish Group. 
  • Presentations at the workshop covered assaults on emergency workers, trading standards staff, transport workers, health and safety law, and social partnership approaches to reducing risk. 
  • To support the Task and Finish Group’s work, a short follow-up survey was issued to workshop attendees. A report on the survey issued to the Group highlighted under-reporting and data gaps as key challenges, with improving reporting and evidence gathering identified as the top priority. It was noted that organisational, evidence and collaborative barriers might impact delivery.
  • Survey respondents reported that success would be reflected in better reporting of incidents, data and evidence gathering, stronger cross-organisational collaboration and the development of cross sector practical tools to reduce the problem and cultural change across organisations.  
  • The next step would be to develop a proposals paper for consultation in September, with a Task and Finish Group meeting planned for October. 

The trade unions stressed the importance of this work and stated their commitment to its continued progress. 

Agenda Item 4: Work Strand 2 equalities barriers to recruitment in the public sector (for discussion)

The Chair explained that progress had also been made under this work-strand including a separate face-face workshop held on the 13 July. Dom Houlihan was invited to provide an update as follows:

  • The workshop included presentations on recruitment barriers and practices from different perspectives including race and disability. 
  • Breakout groups considered priorities, potential outputs, and good practice. Key themes across all groups included the need to improve recruitment processes, increase outreach and awareness, strengthen inclusion, retention and progression practices and enhance training and leadership. 
  • Recommendations included developing a central online hub for guidance, evidence and best practice, improving signposting to existing resources, creating a repository of case studies, developing training resources for applicants, employability staff, HR professionals and hiring managers and considering an evaluation/self-assessment tool for organisations.
  • Some initial examples of guidance and best practice had been collected and would feed into future work. In addition, a library search request had been developed as the first step towards developing a more systematic literature review to support the Group’s work. 
  • The Co-chairs of the Group would meet on the 15 September to agree next steps with the intention of establishing a working group to take forward key recommendations from the workshop. 

The trade unions made the point that it was important to consider career progression as part of the concerns over recruitment practices.

One of the new members of the Forum requested membership of the Task and Finish Group looking at barriers to recruitment in the public sector. 

Action: PSFWF Secretariat to arrange for Angie Feeney to become a member of the Barriers to Recruitment in the Public Sector Task and Finish Group. 

Agenda Item 5: website and resource centre (for agreement)

The Chair reminded members that at the last meeting it had been agreed the Forum’s Resource Centre would be a standing item. It was added that Cardiff City Council’s Migrant Charter had been agreed for inclusion in the Centre and that the secretariat were pursuing a bilingual copy of this. 

The trade unions confirmed they were in the process of obtaining a copy of the Migrant Charter which they would supply soon. They also asked for another document to be included in the Centre Breastfeeding in the Workplace Toolkit. 

Action: PSFWF Secretariat to circulate a link to Public Health Wales’ bilingual Breastfeeding in the Workplace Toolkit to Forum members, seeking their agreement to its inclusion in the Resource Centre. 

Agenda Item 6: national AI governance framework (for discussion)

The Chair explained that TUC Cymru had asked for the National AI Governance Framework to be placed on the agenda. The Welsh Government’s AI lead provided an update on the Framework. 

The Welsh Government confirmed that the Workforce Partnership Council’s (WPC) AI guidance had been disseminated across the public sector to promote its implementation. Separately, other work had focused on developing a better understanding of the support public sector organisations required to use AI. A key finding had been the need for greater rigour relating to accountability, governance and risk management. While broader in scope than the WPC's guidance, the Framework had been designed to complement that work rather than replace it. Over recent months, the Framework had been developed in collaboration with social partners. The first iteration would now be reviewed by AI experts before being circulated for further views. 

The trade unions acknowledged their involvement in the Framework and supported the work that had been done so far, though they felt the document would benefit from greater clarity in some areas. They flagged the pace at which the work was evolving which had sometimes impacted on consultation time and asked why greater prominence had not been given to the environmental impact of AI. 

Welsh Government acknowledged the importance of environmental factors relating to AI and explained that these would be addressed under a separate policy. Welsh Government stressed the pace at which AI was evolving and noted the challenge of balancing this against providing enough time to consult with social partners. 

Agenda Item 7: minutes and matters arising (for agreement)

The Chair outlined matters arising from previous meetings of the Forum which were agreed by members.  

Agenda Item 8: any other business

The trade unions asked if proposals for future workstreams could be placed on the next Forum’s agenda as they had some ideas to share with members.

The Chair stressed the importance of ensuring there were not too many workstreams operating at one time but agreed the proposal with members. 

Action: PSFWF Secretariat to ensure future workstreams are placed on the agenda for the next meeting of the Forum. 

Attendance

  • Stephen Layne (Chair), Welsh Government
  • Sharon West (Deputy), Welsh Government
  • Martin Mansfield, Welsh Government
  • Sharon Davies, WLGA , Employer
  • Beth Rees-Godfrey, WLGA, Employer
  • Dom Houlihan, Welsh Government, Employer
  • Angie Feeney, Sponsored Bodies, Employer
  • Tom Hoyles, GMB, Trade Union
  • Sian Boyles, PCS, Trade Union
  • Mark Turner, Unison, Trade Union
  • Neil Butler, NASUWT, Trade Union
  • Ceri Williams (Nicky Hughes Deputy), TUC Cymru, Trade Union
  • Andrew Cooper,  Aneurin Bevan University Health Board, Employer 
  • Mike Thomas, Welsh Government  

Member absences

  • Nicky Hughes, RCN
  • Samantha Morgan, NHS
  • Reg Kilpatrick, Welsh Government
  • Helen Arthur, Welsh Government
  • Georgina Haarhoff, Welsh Government
  • Mark Lewis, Welsh Government
  • Catherine Evans, Welsh Government
  • Kathleen Mulready, Welsh Government