Skip to main content

Criteria

Weighting (W)

Strategic case: does the scheme demonstrate a sound case for change? Does it fit with the grant purpose/ objectives?

10

Well-being: Does the scheme align with and support Llwybr Newydd: the Wales transport strategy ambitions? Does it maximise contribution to well-being? Does it offer value for money?

5

Management case: is the scheme deliverable and have any milestones been explained? Have the delivery risks been identified and mitigated?

5

Affordability: what is the total scheme cost to Local Transport Fund, Resilient Roads Fund and Ultra Low Emission Vehicle Transformation Fund?

Scoring 
  • <£0.2m = 5
  • £0.2m-£0.49m = 4
  • £0.5m-£0.99m = 3
  • £1m-£4.99m = 2
  • £5m-£9.99m = 1
  • £10m and over = 0

4

Match funding: is match funding available?

Scoring
  • 0% = 0
  • 1%-9% = 1
  • 10%-19% = 2
  • 20%-29% =  3
  • 30%-39% = 4 etc

4

Deliverability: how will the scheme be procured? Is it viable? Does the contract length fit with the grant terms and conditions?

3

Monitoring, evaluation and promotion: does the proposal include plan for monitoring, evaluation and promotion?

3

Notes

a: scoring

5 = outstanding
4 = very good
3 = good
2 = adequate
1 = poor
0 = none or no evidence

b: calculation

The weighting is multiplied by the scoring for the assessment values, which are all added together to give the final value.